In August of 2020, my boyfriend broke up with me.
It was weird. I was moving. I ended up sitting naked in the bathtub, a pipe in my hand that I was crying too hard to suck on, utterly overwhelmed with grief and confusion. This break-up did not fit with the scripts I had derived from previous ones – I couldn’t feel angry even when I tried. Every reason he gave me for breaking up with me made sense and left little room for self-blame. I ended up telling him, through tears, that I was proud of him for putting himself first, and I meant it. It wasn’t lost on either of us that I’d helped him build the skill of putting himself first to start with, but I couldn’t resent myself for that, either. I had so much emotion and so few places to put it.
It took me a long time to go back to being Friends with him, which is what he’d said he wanted. He was terrified of losing our friendship, and so was I, but I waited.
Some of it was simply to let the raw feelings peak and subside, so that I didn’t cry all over him the first time that we hung out. Most of the delay, though, was caused by a bitter argument I was having with myself about how to be his friend.
There was a part of me that believed in my ability to “win him back”, and I did not want to give that part of me the reins. Consciously, in my Logic Brain, I’ve never believed in “winning” or “deserving” people, and I wasn’t about to start here, with a person who had done so much hard work on self-determination and holding his own boundaries. Less consciously, though, my brain was churning out ideas for grand romantic gestures and irresistibly hot outfits, ways to make him jealous and ways I could make myself irreplaceable. I kept my distance until I could be sure that I was rejoining his life as his friend, and not as his jilted ex seeking to manipulate him.
The waiting hurt, though.
We eased back into each other’s lives with all the grace of a reversing dump truck. Things were tentative and awkward, in some ways, and in other ways it felt like I had never been gone. There was still stuff of mine at his house – even after he moved. The in-jokes still cracked us both up. And for every cruel moment wherein it felt like nothing had changed, I paid for in pain when I remembered: we’re just friends.
He had surgery, and I didn’t Google the procedure. I couldn’t bring myself to. But I brought myself to his house. He couldn’t blow up his airbed, he said, because of the surgery, and I was welcome to sleep in his bed with him anyhow. I spent hours awake next to him, barely hanging onto the edge of the mattress, listening to him breathing. I thought and thought about the pain I was in, and whether I would ever deem it to have been worthwhile. The thought of losing his friendship was devastating, but spending time with him was torture. Would it ever hurt less? Did I want it to hurt less, or did I feel like the pain at least kept some part of our romantic love preserved? Was I a better friend for being here, even though it hurt? Would I have ever, in any universe, decided not to go and see him after surgery? Was I imagining his regret and grief and poorly-concealed feelings for me? Questions chased each other around my skull as YouTube autoplayed hits from artists I never usually listened to. When Ed Sheeran’s Perfect came on, I almost turned the TV off, but the background noise was helping my platonic friendo sleep next to me, so I suffered and I suffered.
(Later, my fiancee would hear this story, and point out that surgery shouldn’t have affected my ex’s ability to blow up his airbed, because his airbed came with a pump that plugged into the mains and blew the fucker up for you.)
Most of the time, I respected his decision, and I made myself content with his friendship. Unfortunately, Drunk Morgan did not always get this memo.
This paragraph exists largely to thank my other partner in Stoke, my fiancee and my mother, all of whom dealt with a number of my wobbles with patience and compassion. Drunk Morgan swung wildly between “I have to win him back,” and “I have to ghost him,” neither of which were what Sober Morgan wanted. I would sob to anyone but him about how badly I wanted him back, and respond to every gentle suggestion that I tell him that with more wailing about how he wouldn’t and shouldn’t take me back. Things that I was able to repress when sober felt like they might crush me when I drank, especially around him.
This is not to say that Sober Morgan was perfect, either, just a little calmer – but equally as stubborn. I would beg my mum to tell me definitively that we would get back together, which she was smart enough to avoid doing. I would lament and lament to my partner in Stoke but shut down every suggestion they began with, “What if you told him -”
I was something of a nightmare.
In the two years that we weren’t together, lots of things happened.
Without putting all of his business online, it was at midnight on the motorway from Nottingham to The South™ that I realised: this boy could’ve relegated me to Acquaintance and I would still be in the passenger seat, on the phone with him, doing my damnedest to keep him safe. It didn’t matter that it was approaching 5am when we got him home – we got him home.
At some point, we started going to shows together again. The first time, we had two mates with us as something of a buffer, but that didn’t stop me needing a quick cry in the bathroom. I thought I could get away with it – I was the only one of the four of us who was welcome in the Ladies’ bathroom – but he saw my face afterwards and voiced concern. I realised then that the sign on the door wouldn’t have mattered, that he would’ve walked into Hell itself if he thought I wasn’t safe, and it was hard work not to start crying again.
We went to see our favourite band as just the two of us. I checked the setlist in the hostel we were staying in but I didn’t tell him what I had found – that Our Song, from when we were a couple, was first up on every setlist I could find. I knew full well I wouldn’t get away with slipping off to the bathroom for the first song of the set, so I reverted to Plan B. I got really quite drunk. Perhaps for similar reasons, he got really quite drunk as well. By the time that I had shepherded him back to the hostel, he was swaying. I sat him in a leather armchair and smiled nicely at the guy who was using the kitchen table for his crossword as I filled a glass of water.
When I thrust it at my ex with the pronouncement, “Do you want a drink of water? That’s an instruction,” I heard Crossword Guy chuckle.
I wasn’t able to sober my ex up quite enough, because when we got back to our room, he threw up into a mesh wastepaper basket, and thus also all over the floor. I’ve always been the strongest-stomached out of most groups of people, and vomit is kind of my specialty after all the years of bulimia (not to brag or anything). I cleaned up with the efficiency of a serial killer and stationed my ex in front of the toilet, occasionally fanning him, occasionally reminding him to sip water, promising him that he would feel better soon.
I couldn’t stop reflecting on how gorgeous I found him, even having just mopped up the contents of his stomach. I told myself it was because I was drunk, but truthfully the vomiting incident and subsequent rapid cleanup had sobered me up plenty.
I wondered if it was noble to love someone like this, even when they didn’t return the feeling. Maybe it was just pathetic. I wrote some bad poetry and went to sleep feeling raw.
People started running out of patience.
I think that as soon as it was clarified to one member of the polycule that our feelings were definitely still mutual, both of my partners (and my mum, who isn’t a member of my polycule but is part of my family) quickly became just a smidge frustrated. They loved me, sure, but they also loved him, and could see how much pain we were both in. Even when they managed to hound us into Conversations About Our Feelings, we were avoidant and frightened and prone to breaking into banter instead of focusing on the matter at hand. For a while, things existed in a very weird place.
He admitted to me that his Feelings were definitely romantic, but also that he was scared of needing to break up with me again. In his words, “It’s fine that you have a lot of baggage, but I don’t want us to get back together until I’m hench enough to carry it without putting it back down again.” I pointed out all the ways things were stabilising around us but I didn’t press the issue, and I didn’t say “I’d take ten more breakups if it meant ten days of being your partner again.” We kept getting a tiny ways into the conversation that would get us back together and then getting distracted, and in my case at least, scared.
It was my other Stoke partner who finally broke the silence. Specifically, they messaged him and they messaged me, telling us we had an hour to start The Conversation before they phoned or messaged the group chat to start it for us. It still took us some procrastinating (which, as I’m sure you’ve gathered, is our specialty) but we did it. We laid our guts out to each other and I admitted to some of the more cringe pining I had done, and somehow in amongst the banter, as naturally as our usual conversation, The Conversation established we were a couple again.
It felt like a weight had lifted from my chest. I got teary.
When he started to look at universities outside of England, I soothed the pang of don’t-leave-me-sadness with the more dominant feeling of relief and excitement that he was going to end up somewhere he felt safe.
That somewhere ended up being Liverpool, which is in England and not too far from Stoke, but he was still Going Away to somewhere outside of my two usual haunts. He seemed eager to soothe my above-mentioned sadness too, before I even voiced it, telling me about the drawer of my stuff I could have at his place.
On the 4/20 of 2023, I went to his place with my Daddy, who in typical Daddy form busied herself with fixing my boyfriend’s new bike. She found reason (legitimate reason, to be fair) to go to Halford’s, and my boyfriend nipped into another room only to return with a red drawstring pouch in hand.
The first thing I noticed was his hands shaking, and then that he was down on one knee. And I knew.
His voice shook. So did mine, I’m sure, when I responded to him proposing to me with a near-automatic yes. Two years of pining suddenly felt very short and very worth it in retrospect, but this is also a story about how pining alone will not move things along. Unfortunately, both parties have to be brave, repeatedly.
But we were. We could have suffered for decades, but we were brave.
If you enjoyed this post, why not follow me on X (the artist formerly known as Twitter) to see when other posts go live? Or check out some more of my relationships-related content!